41 North DigitalThe Local Holiday Edit • 2026 holiday edition
Borough harbor and an illustrated lighthouse
Harbor lights, hand-painted buoys, and gifts with a story

Stonington Holiday Gift Guide

Start in Stonington Borough for Water Street’s shops and the Lobster Trap Tree. Then make a separate stop at the Velvet Mill for maker gifts and pastry, or head to Pawcatuck for a secondhand treasure. This guide skips downtown Mystic and Olde Mistick Village so the Borough and neighboring Stonington villages get their own spotlight.

Find a giftPlan your dayAll town guidesYear-round Shop Local guide

Find their kind of gift.

Pick who you’re shopping for, or tap a heart to add an idea to My List on this device.

Editor’s picks

Cover of The Pocket Book of Stones
Mountain Hollow

Mountain Hollow

Velvet Mill

The Pocket Book of Stones

An illustrated pocket guide for the person who always comes home with interesting rocks.

$14.99

See the gift
Maggie Lee Designs sterling silver lobster-pot buoy jewelry
Maggie Lee Designs

Maggie Lee Designs

Water Street · Stonington Borough

Sterling silver lobster-pot buoy charm

A keepsake from a jeweler with a Water Street studio that echoes the painted buoys on the Borough’s holiday tree. Ask which buoy style is currently available.

Ask the shop
New England Science & Sailing community sailing on the water
New England Science & Sailing

New England Science & Sailing

Water Street · Stonington Borough

Learn to Sail Level 1

Give a future day on the water instead of another thing to unwrap. Ask NESS about the next season’s dates and how to give a lesson.

See experience details
Interior of Unexpected Treasures Thrift Store in Pawcatuck
Pawcatuck Neighborhood Center

Unexpected Treasures Thrift Store

Pawcatuck

A gently used toy or pet item

Browse changing stock at the Pawcatuck Neighborhood Center for a small surprise without buying new.

Visit the shop
My Perfect Bliss Cherry Vanilla Candle
My Perfect Bliss

My Perfect Bliss

Stonington maker · online

Cherry Vanilla Candle

A cozy cherry-and-vanilla candle from a Stonington maker. Check size options on the product page.

See the gift
Cover of the Stonington lighthouse history booklet
Historic Stonington

Historic Stonington

Stonington Borough · online shop

Stonington’s Old Lighthouse and It’s Keepers

A short local-history gift for lighthouse fans and anyone who knows the Point by heart.

$10

See the gift
Handwoven Papatya-pattern towels
Photo: Yali Stonington

Yali Stonington

Stonington Borough · online shop

Handwoven Papatya cotton towel

A flat-woven Turkish cotton towel that works as a colorful kitchen staple, powder-room accent, or wrapping for another gift.

$28

See the gift
Hand-painted floral snow globe ornament
Photo: Glaze Handmade

Glaze Handmade

Stonington Road · Stonington

Floral snow globe ornament

A hand-painted ceramic ornament from Lyndsay Meiklem Dean’s Stonington studio for someone whose tree doubles as a collection.

$40

See the gift
Handmade wild-clay cup by Matt Fishman
Mountain Hollow

Mountain Hollow

Velvet Mill

Handmade wild-clay cup

This 8–10 ounce ceramic cup by Matt Fishman is made for slower coffee or tea. Materials and finish vary naturally.

$48

See the gift
Examples of hand-bound upcycled-leather journals
Photo: Shuttle Press & Bindery

Shuttle Press & Bindery

Velvet Mill

An upcycled-leather journal

A hand-bound journal with character for a writer, traveler, or enthusiastic list maker. Ask about the studio’s current selection.

Ask the shop

For your significant other

Horizontal heart necklace displayed on driftwood
Photo via Stonington Designs
Local gift

Stonington Designs

Stonington maker · online

A reclaimed-wood heart necklace

A tiny heart etched into woven holly and cherry wood. For someone who likes jewelry with a quieter story than a big sparkle.

See the gift
Classes & experiences

The Inn at Stonington

Water Street · Stonington Borough

A harbor-view overnight for two

Give them a night away without a long drive. Room 1 has a harbor-facing balcony, fireplace and soaking tub; choose dates together.

See experience details
A floral arrangement shown by Pot of Green Florist
Photo via Pot of Green Florist
Local gift

Pot of Green Florist

Pawcatuck

A bouquet in their favorite colors

Ask the Pawcatuck florist to build an arrangement around colors or flowers that mean something to your person. Confirm availability and pickup or delivery.

Ask about it
Candlelit reception at Stone Acres Farm, venue photo
Photo via Stone Acres Farm
Classes & experiences

Stone Acres Farm

North Main Street · Stonington

New Year’s Eve supper for two at the farm

Turn the gift into a date: reserve seats for the December 31 three-course Supper Club and let the farm handle dinner. Check reservations before gifting.

See experience details
Classes & experiences

The Folk School at Stone Acres Farm

North Main Street · Stonington

Make hand-stitched coasters together

Reserve seats for the January 9, 2027 quilted-coaster workshop. You each get a small reminder of the morning you spent together.

See experience details

Stocking stuffers & small gifts

Apolis Craft Tea from Mountain Hollow
Mountain Hollow

Mountain Hollow

Velvet Mill

Apolis craft tea

Pick a blend for someone who looks forward to the first quiet cup of the day. The shop lists individual tea options.

$16.99

See the gift
Set of Rollie McKenna postcards from Historic Stonington
Historic Stonington

Historic Stonington

Stonington Borough · online shop

Set of 10 Rollie McKenna postcards

A small present for the person who saves real mail, or a local set to use for thank-you notes.

$5

See the gift
Hand-painted Scrappy Cat ceramic mini sculpture
Photo: Glaze Handmade

Glaze Handmade

Stonington Road · Stonington

Scrappy Cat mini sculpture

A small hand-painted ceramic cat for a cat person’s bookshelf or desk. Let them choose their favorite color if stock varies.

$18

See the gift
Marsha York ornament depicting the Stonington lighthouse
Photo: Historic Stonington

Historic Stonington

Water Street · Stonington Borough

Marsha York lighthouse ornament

A small Stonington keepsake for the tree, offered by the museum’s Palmer House gift shop.

$30

See the gift
Bottle of Devil’s Apron kelp hot sauce
Photo: Stonington Kelp Co.

Stonington Kelp Co.

Stonington maker · online

Devil’s Apron kelp hot sauce

A small, locally made pantry gift for the person who splashes hot sauce on everything from eggs to oysters.

$15

See the gift
Cover of Sandra Boynton’s Woodland Dance! board book
Photo: Modern Heritage Collective

Modern Heritage Collective

Velvet Mill

Woodland Dance! board book

A Sandra Boynton story small enough for a stocking, for a toddler and their favorite person to read with. Check the shop for Velvet Mill pickup.

$7.99

See the gift

My Perfect Bliss

Stonington maker · online

Apple Of My Eye Soap Bar

A small handcrafted gift from a Stonington maker, easy to tuck into a stocking.

$10

See the gift

Stonington Community Center

Cutler Street · Stonington

COMO class and activity gift card

A flexible gift for someone who would enjoy trying a local class but wants to choose the activity and date.

From $25

See gift card details

Give them something to do

A class, a day out, or an evening together.

Whitecrest Eatery’s own restaurant photograph
Venue photo: Whitecrest Eatery

Whitecrest Eatery

Velvet Mill

Dinner in the Velvet Mill

Take the person who loves trying a new menu out to the Mill for a chef-owned dinner. Book a table rather than counting on a gift certificate.

See booking options

See outing details
Outdoor seating and the entrance at the original Dog Watch Café
Venue photo: Dog Watch Café

Dog Watch Café

Water Street · Stonington Borough

Harbor lunch at Dog Watch Café

Treat someone to scallops or chowder at the original waterfront café in Stonington Borough. The restaurant offers both electronic and mailed gift cards.

See booking options

See outing details
Sunset on the water at the Stonington Breakwater
Venue photo: Dream Stonington

Dream Stonington

Water Street · Stonington Borough

Private sunset at the Stonington Breakwater

A special-occasion splurge for up to six guests on a 56-foot yacht at its mooring, with drinks and hors d’oeuvres. Ask the operator about future dates.

$1,800 for six

See outing details
Example of the instructor’s colorful painted artwork
Photo: Lindberg Designs

Lindberg Designs

Quanaduck Road · Stonington

A studio painting class

Give a creative person an evening to paint in a Stonington studio. Group classes are by RSVP; confirm the schedule and supplies with the artist.

See booking options

See outing details
Kelp being harvested at Stonington Kelp Co.
Venue photo: Stonington Kelp Co.

Stonington Kelp Co.

Stonington shoreline

An inquiry for a future kelp-farm boat tour

For a curious cook or ocean lover, ask when tours open again to see a working kelp farm. Dates are seasonal; no upcoming departure is assumed.

See booking options

See outing details

La Grua Center

Stonington Borough · online shop

A Charlie Brown Christmas jazz concert

Give the person who plays this soundtrack every December an afternoon with the Jerrod Cattey Trio. December 12 at 5 p.m.; check tickets before gifting.

$25 advance

See outing details
BESPOKE’s chalkboard and lights in its Velvet Mill cycling studio
Photo via BESPOKE

BESPOKE

Velvet Mill

An indoor cycling drop-in

For someone who likes to unwind by moving. Browse instructor-led indoor rides at the Velvet Mill, 22 Bayview Avenue, Studio 62.

Browse and book classes

For the host or homebody

For the table, the kitchen, and a cozier night in.

Sourdough bagels from Flour Shop Bagels
Photo: Flour Shop Bagels

Flour Shop Bagels

Pawcatuck

A sourdough bagel breakfast in Pawcatuck

Bring hand-rolled sourdough bagels to a slow holiday morning, or take someone to breakfast. Check the shop’s current pickup details.

See the gift

Meryl + Masa

Velvet Mill

Signature sourdough loaf

An easy edible host gift from the Velvet Mill bakery. Bring the loaf with good butter, or use it to start a holiday breakfast.

See the gift

Stone Acres Farm

North Main Street · Stonington

Build a farmstand host basket

Pick a few seasonal pantry staples and handmade goods at the farmstand for an edible gift. This is a build-your-own idea, not a premade basket.

Browse the shop
The two ceramic Mother of Pearl Oyster Trays from Ahmee Ceramics
Photo via Ahmee Ceramics
Local gift

Ahmee Ceramics

Velvet Mill studio · Stonington

Mother of Pearl Oyster Tray, two-piece set

Two sculptural oyster-shaped ceramic trays for a shoreline table or a spot to drop rings. The maker offers pickup at the Stonington studio.

$78

See the gift
A handmade pressed-dahlia-leaf dish from Glaze Handmade
Photo via Glaze Handmade
Local gift

Glaze Handmade

Stonington Road · Stonington

Pressed Dahlia Leaf Dish

The maker presses real dahlia leaves into the clay. Use the dish as a spoon rest or a little catchall by the door. Each is slightly different.

$52

See the gift
Yali’s flat-woven Raylar Stripe cotton throw in Salmon
Photo via Yali Stonington
Local gift

Yali Stonington

Stonington Borough · online shop

Raylar Stripe cotton throw in Salmon

A lightweight handwoven Turkish cotton throw with warm stripes. Use it on the back of a chair or pack it for a beach day. Yali is Stonington-based and sells online.

$65

See the gift
Engraved wooden serving boards beside patterned tea towels at Wm. Cole in Stonington
Image via Wm. Cole
Home & hosting

Wm. Cole

Stonington Road · Stonington

An engraved wooden serving board

An engraved wooden board for a holiday host. Visit Wm. Cole at 862 Stonington Road or call ahead to ask about current designs.

See store details

More local finds

Ahmee Ceramics Pepper Mug
Ahmee Ceramics

Ahmee Ceramics

Velvet Mill studio · Stonington

Pepper Mug

A functional, handmade Stonington mug for someone whose favorite morning ritual is already set. The shop provides local pickup instructions.

$52

See the gift
Stonington Vineyards gift card design
Photo: Stonington Vineyards

Stonington Vineyards

Taugwonk Road · Stonington

Digital tasting-room gift card

Give someone 21 or older an excuse to plan a tasting-room visit. The vineyard says the digital card is valid in its tasting room and online shop.

See gift card details
Examples of indigo-dyed scarves by fiber + mud
Photo: fiber + mud

fiber + mud

Velvet Mill

Hand-dyed indigo scarf

A textile in the maker’s signature blue for the person who loves fabrics with visible handwork. Ask the studio which patterns are available.

Ask the shop

Zest Fresh Pastry

Velvet Mill

A box of Zest Mallowmars

Chocolate-dipped marshmallow and graham cracker make a playful gift to share. Confirm quantity and the day’s selection with the bakery.

Ask the shop

Sally Vail at Home

Cutler Street · Stonington

Guest towels or table linens

A practical host gift from a constantly changing selection. Shop in person to see current colors and styles.

Visit the shop

Grand & Water Antiques

Water Street · Stonington Borough

A small vintage decorative object

Browse one-of-a-kind finds for the person who would rather have something with a past. Ask about any piece you see online.

Ask the shop

The Tranquil Owl

Velvet Mill

A therapeutic massage to look forward to

A quiet-hour gift for someone who would rather book a break. Send an eGift card from the Velvet Mill studio.

Buy an eGift card

Bogue’s Alley

Pawcatuck

A Pawcatuck lunch outing

Take a friend or the person who already has everything to this neighborhood bistro for lunch and a daily special.

Visit the shop

Historic Stonington

Stonington Borough · online shop

A Historic Stonington gift membership

For the local history buff who always has another question. Members can visit the museums and archives; the Lighthouse Museum is scheduled to reopen in May 2027.

See gift card details
Raw rainbow moonstone and copper stud earrings from Mountain Hollow
Photo via Mountain Hollow
Local gift

Mountain Hollow

Velvet Mill

Raw rainbow moonstone and copper earrings

A small jewelry gift with naturally irregular pale stones and warm copper settings. Individual shapes vary.

$45

See the gift

Make a day of it

Holiday stops in Stonington

Year-round Shop Local

A Water Street walk before the harbor lights

  1. Maggie Lee DesignsStart at 135 Water Street and browse the coastal jewelry collection.
  2. Wadawanuck SquareWalk to the Stonington Free Library plaza, the starting point for the Dec. 4 holiday stroll.
  3. Lobster Trap TreeContinue on foot to the Town Docks at 1 High Street. Check the official lighting schedule and weather notices.

Keep exploring

Suggest a local business

Guide updated Nov. 20, 2026. Confirm current prices, stock, gift-card terms, hours and event details with the merchant or organizer before you go.

Cover artwork: original illustration by 41 North Digital.