41 North DigitalThe Local Holiday Edit • 2026 holiday edition
Original illustration of a warmly lit yellow house by Old Lyme’s Lieutenant River
The shoreline shop-small edition

Old Lyme Holiday Gift Guide

Art supplies, the good things on Halls Road, and reasons to share a night on Lyme Street.

Find a giftPlan your dayAll town guidesYear-round Shop Local guide

Gifts with an Old Lyme story.

Browse the full guide, filter for someone, or save an idea to My List on this device.

Editor’s picks

Classes & experiences

The Side Door Jazz Club

Lyme Street Arts District

A live jazz date on Lyme Street

Pick a show and make a night of it in the small club next to the Old Lyme Inn. Check the calendar before choosing.

See experience details
Local gift

de Gerenday’s

Lyme Street Arts District

Holbein Artists’ watercolor set

For a watercolor painter who likes a sketchbook in their bag. Choose the set that fits their palette rather than guessing at one color.

See the gift
Northern Shores 1,000-piece jigsaw puzzle from The Bowerbird
Photo via The Bowerbird
Local gift

The Bowerbird

Halls Road

Northern Shores 1,000-piece jigsaw

Wrap it with something to snack on and give yourselves a winter evening in.

See the gift
Brooklyn Candle Studio Catskills Classic two-wick candle
Photo via Homeward Collective
Local gift

Homeward Collective

Nearby + online · Essex & Madison

Catskills Classic two-wick candle

For the partner who likes woodsy scents and an evening at home. The shop describes a cedar-and-cypress scent.

See the gift
Local gift

Florence Griswold Museum

Lyme Street Arts District

A household museum membership

For the person you always say we should go back with: a household membership includes general admission and savings at the museum shop. Ask the museum how to buy it for someone else.

See membership details

Give them something to do

Local gift

Old Lyme Inn

Lyme Street Arts District

An inn stay, dinner or a jazz gift certificate

Let them choose a night away, dinner, or tickets at the Side Door. The inn says the same certificate can be used for all three.

See gift card details
Classes & experiences

Florence Griswold Museum

Lyme Street Arts District

A holiday tea at Miss Florence’s

Tea in the decorated Marshfield House is a December outing to share. Check seat availability with the museum before making plans.

See experience details
Local gift

Lyme Art Association

Lyme Street Arts District

A piece of art chosen together

Visit the historic gallery and look for a piece by a regional artist that feels like home. Ask the gallery what’s available for sale.

Visit the shop
Classes & experiences

The Hangry Goose

Halls Road

A waterfront breakfast date

Take someone out for breakfast before a walk or a shop stop. The restaurant is on Halls Road overlooking the Lieutenant River.

See experience details
Musical Masterworks performing in Old Lyme
Photo via Musical Masterworks
Classes & experiences

Musical Masterworks

Lyme Street Arts District

Chamber music tickets for two

Choose a performance at the First Congregational Church of Old Lyme. The December concerts bring strings, flute, piano and banjo together.

See experience details
Classes & experiences

Black Hall Marina

Shore Road & Black Hall

A future kayak outing for two

Give a warm-weather day to look forward to. The Old Lyme location focuses on paddle sports; check seasonal rentals and conditions before gifting.

See paddling options
Classes & experiences

Lyme Art Association

Lyme Street Arts District

A winter watercolor workshop

Give an afternoon of color in February. Lisa Miceli’s land-and-seascapes workshop is listed for Feb. 20, 2027; check remaining seats before gifting.

See experience details
Classes & experiences

Studio 80 + Sculpture Grounds

Lyme Street Arts District

An outdoor sculpture walk together

Put a date on the calendar to wander the riverside sculpture grounds together. Check visitor hours and dress for the weather.

See experience details

More Old Lyme finds

Dinosaurs Seek & Find 100-Piece Puzzle box from The Bowerbird
Photo via The Bowerbird
Kids & families

The Bowerbird

Halls Road

Dinosaurs Seek & Find 100-Piece Puzzle

Put the dinosaur puzzle together, then look for the hidden items. Ages 5 and up. The Halls Road shop lists local pickup; check stock before going.

$14.99

See the dinosaur puzzle
Painted Pinocchio wooden spinning top from de Gerenday’s
Photo via de Gerenday’s
Small gifts

de Gerenday’s

Lyme Street Arts District

Pinocchio wooden spinning top

A small wooden top with a familiar storybook face. Check stock with the Lyme Street shop if you’re stopping in.

$6.70

See the wooden top
Food & sweets

The Chocolate Shell

Lyme Street Arts District

A six-piece truffle box

Bring a small box of truffles to dinner or split it after a holiday walk. The shop lists a pre-packed six-piece option; check flavors and current pricing in store.

Call the shop
Bottle of Fat Stone Farm dark pure maple syrup
Photo via The Bowerbird
Local gift

The Bowerbird

Halls Road

Fat Stone Farm dark maple syrup

Make a slow breakfast part of the gift. Pair the dark syrup with their favorite pancake mix.

See the gift
Local gift

FloGris Shop

Lyme Street Arts District

The Charm of the Place: Old Lyme in the 1920s

A local-history gift for someone who notices the old buildings on Lyme Street. The book follows a hand-painted stage curtain and the town it advertised.

See the gift
de Gerenday’s gift card
Photo via de Gerenday’s
Local gift

de Gerenday’s

Lyme Street Arts District

An art-supply shop gift card

A practical gift for the person who would rather choose their own paper, paint, or brushes. The shop is on the Lyme Academy campus.

See gift card details
Local gift

Coffee’s Country Market

Boston Post Road

An artisanal cheese platter

A no-cooking contribution to a holiday get-together: choose a cheese platter with fruit and crackers from the market’s catering menu.

See the catering menu
Local gift

Coffee’s Country Market

Boston Post Road

A market gift card for a cozy dinner in

Let them pick specialty groceries and prepared food for a night when nobody wants to cook. The market lists gift cards on its site.

See gift card details
Local gift

Phoebe’s BookCellar

Lyme Street Arts District

A used book with a note tucked inside

Visit the volunteer-run shop on the lower level of the Old Lyme library. Look for an art book, a classic, or a story for a young reader.

Visit the shop
Local gift

Old Lyme Historical Society

Lyme Street Arts District

An Old Lyme map tea towel

A small gift for the person who always knows the back roads. The shop’s towel uses a color version of a historic town engraving.

Visit the shop
Local gift

EF Watermelon

Lyme Street Arts District

Artisan or estate jewelry on Lyme Street

A splurge to choose in person. The gallery carries jewelry by American artisans and estate pieces; ask about options in your budget.

Visit the shop
Local gift

The Lyme Tree

Halls Road

A handmade gift from the Woman’s Exchange

Browse the volunteer-run gift shop for something handcrafted. It’s a good stop when you prefer to pick a one-of-a-kind gift in person.

Visit the shop
White floral arrangement in a birch-wrapped vessel from Elements
Photo via Elements
Flowers & home

Elements

Old Lyme delivery

Birch Wrapped Elegance

Send a winter table arrangement in a birch-wrapped vessel. Stems vary by season; see the florist’s delivery details.

From $85

See the birch arrangement

A nearby favorite: Homeward Collective

Olive mini-gingham oven mitt and matching potholder
Photo via Homeward Collective
Local gift

Homeward Collective

Nearby + online · Essex & Madison

Olive gingham oven mitt and potholder

A quilted linen set for the person who always volunteers to bake.

See the gift
Olive-striped oatmeal linen dinner napkins
Photo via Homeward Collective
Local gift

Homeward Collective

Nearby + online · Essex & Madison

Olive stripe linen dinner napkins

Four soft oatmeal linen napkins with olive stripes, easy to work into a dinner table year-round.

See the gift
Baudelaire large bath sea sponge gift box
Photo via Homeward Collective
Local gift

Homeward Collective

Nearby + online · Essex & Madison

Baudelaire bath sea sponge gift box

A bath-time upgrade already boxed for gifting. Pair it with their favorite soap if you know the scent they like.

See the gift
Tiepology rectangle claw clip in tortoise
Photo via Homeward Collective
Local gift

Homeward Collective

Nearby + online · Essex & Madison

Tortoise rectangular claw clip

A simple stocking gift if they like an easy hair-up option. This is the tortoise shade.

See the gift

Holiday stops in Old Lyme

An Old Lyme afternoon

Lyme Street, then Halls Road

  1. de Gerenday’s84 Lyme Street · Start at the Lyme Academy shop and browse art supplies and small gifts.
  2. Old Lyme Inn85 Lyme Street · Cross for a meal or plan tickets to the Side Door Jazz Club; check the current schedule first.
  3. Lyme Art Association90 Lyme Street · Explore the gallery and ask about work by regional artists.
  4. Florence Griswold Museum96 Lyme Street · Leave time for the museum shop, galleries, and grounds overlooking the Lieutenant River.
  5. The Bowerbird46 Halls Road · Make this a separate stop for gifts, jewelry, books and things to take to a holiday host.

Homeward Collective’s current stores are in Essex and Madison. Shop its Old Lyme guide picks online or make a separate trip.

Keep exploring

Guide updated Nov. 20, 2026. Confirm prices, inventory, hours and event availability with the shop or organizer.

Cover artwork: original illustration by 41 North Digital.